The insurers we compare
Shopt quotes with specialist collector car insurance companies, not general auto insurers.
Shopt currently compares quotes from four collector car insurance companies: American Collectors Insurance, Grundy, Hagerty and OpenRoad. Each one decides for itself whether it can quote your vehicle in your state, so the number of quotes you receive can vary.
| Insurance company | What it is |
|---|---|
| American Collectors Insurance | Collector vehicle insurance specialist (part of Philadelphia Insurance Companies). |
| Grundy | Collector car insurance specialist. |
| Hagerty | Collector car insurance and enthusiast brand. |
| OpenRoad | Collector and enthusiast vehicle insurance program. |
Why compare specialists?
Collector car insurers write policies for vehicles that are driven occasionally, stored carefully and often valued well above a normal used car. Their pricing, coverage options, mileage rules and eligibility differ from each other — and from a standard auto policy — so the same car can be quoted very differently by each company. Shopt lets you see those differences side by side.
Do I deal with the insurance companies?
No. Shopt handles the quoting, and a licensed agent at Covenant Underwriters LLC handles the purchase. You only hear from Shopt.
Updated October 2026. Shopt is not owned by or affiliated with any of these insurance companies; Covenant Underwriters LLC is an appointed agency.
Ready when you are
One form, up to 15 vehicles, quotes from specialist collector car insurers. No phone calls required.
Get my quotes